An Army Marches on Its Stomach

A woman wearing a blue hat and glasses smiles warmly.

       Have you heard the expression, “An Army marches on its stomach”? It is frequently and erroneously attributed to Napoleon Bonaparte, but whoever said it first certainly was right. Logistics may not be the sexiest job in the military, but it is certainly critically important.

Or, as I have often quoted, “No food, one problem. Enough food, many problems.” Essentially, if you don’t have enough food, nothing else matters. Every other problem dissolves in the face of the overriding need for sustenance.

How many of you ever ate in a Chow Hall? A Mess Hall? Any other names? In recent years we have upgraded terminology—we now eat in the DFAC, short for Dining Facility.

Army food has a bad reputation, but I’m here to tell you that the food in the DFAC is NOT bad. Of course, you have to watch out for the bacon that can and will be slipped into the strangest places.  And, in my experience, the closer you get to combat, the better the quality of the food. I guess that is some compensation for the increased danger.

However, it doesn’t matter how close you are to the front, alcohol is prohibited for US troops. There are two exceptions. On Super Bowl Sunday, each Soldier is typically entitled to two beers—provided the local commander authorizes it and the operational mission allows for it. And wine is permitted for religious ceremonies.

Thus, as you can imagine, Friday night services down range were quite popular, and the rule of thumb was that no wine was left over. Sadly, the wine procured by our beloved Quartermasters is typically pretty awful, but I guess if it’s all you’ve got…

There was the time I was heading to Iraq for Passover. I bought three bottles of lovely French, kosher wine for the seders. Two were confiscated by customs in Kuwait, but I managed to smuggle one in. At the seder at Forward Operating Base Taji, one of the participants memorably commented, “We would lick the inside of the bottle if we could.”

When a unit goes to the field, the food is prepared in an MKT—a mobile kitchen trailer designed to feed several hundred troops. More recently the Army has deployed CKs, containerized kitchens, which can serve up to 800 troops three hot meals a day.

What were your field rations when you served? I’m guessing maybe C-rats? A full day’s worth of C-rations consisted of six small tin cans—three “M-units” for meat and three “B-units” for bread and biscuits. You got a heavy main course, some rock-hard crackers, and an accessory pack with a can opener and some cigarettes.

In my day, we ate MREs—officially Meals Ready to Eat, or, colloquially, meals refusing to exit. There was that time in Korea.  My colleague and I journeyed from our campsite at Camp Humphreys to Camp Carol to Pohang, where I was scheduled to pick up the first in a series of flights home.  My unit greatly respected my not traveling on Shabbat, so they arranged a whole, individual itinerary for me.

Imagine my disappointment when we finally arrived at the flight line- it took two days to get there- and the LT at the desk told us the flight had been re-routed, was leaving from 2 hours away, and we had to turn back to Camp Humphreys.

I was so discouraged that I climbed into the bak of our CUCVC- Combat Utility Cargo Vehicle- to retrieve some M&Ms as a bit of comfort food.  They didn’t taste quite right, and when I looked carefully the package had expired 8 years prior!

The Army actually has kosher and halal MREs, but I thought I’d show and tell what a typical MRE looks like. (Open and share)

Now, aside from showing off some classic culinary logistics, why am I sharing all of these fun facts? Well, it IS our Veterans Day service, so a focus on the military seemed appropriate. But there’s a more personal reason, too. We recently had a retreat for our Temple Chai Board members, and I shared with one of our folks that I don’t like to stand in line for food. I’d rather wait for the crowd to finish, having spent too much time in line for food—and everything else—in my 38 years in the Army.

And, more importantly than my own personal preference, it is also standard operating procedure that “officers eat last.” It would be considered unseemly for an officer to be seated with a meal while their Soldiers are still hungry.

I am touched by the respect that this custom reflects, and I think that being considerate of others—in the words of Mussar, taking no more than my place—is a healthy way of cultivating humility.

Letting others go first and waiting patiently are two lessons learned.

And I stand in humility before my fellow veterans who honor us tonight by their presence. If you are a veteran, I invite you to please rise at this time and share a bit about where and when you served, in what branch and what capacity, and anything else you’d like us to know.